Thursday, March 6, 2008

Ecuador's recent clash with Columbia

A New York Times Editorial, from today:

South America has had more than its share of border conflicts. Still, it is hard to believe that in the 21st century the democratically elected governments of Colombia, Ecuador and Venezuela would be talking about war.

Colombia’s decision to send forces into Ecuador on Saturday to kill a Colombian guerrilla commander was an infringement of Ecuador’s sovereignty — a sensitive issue anywhere, but especially in Latin America. Ecuador immediately severed diplomatic ties and said it would move troops to its northern border with Colombia. Venezuela — whose territory wasn’t violated — jumped in. President Hugo Chávez, who thrives on such crises, expelled Colombia’s ambassador, ordered forces to his border and threatened to block trade. Colombia then accused both Venezuela and Ecuador of aiding and abetting the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, the guerrilla group known as FARC.

We were reassured Wednesday that the Organization of American States has now decided to send a commission to investigate the raid and convene a meeting of foreign ministers to consider the results.

Ecuador and Colombia must settle their differences through diplomatic means. As a first step, Ecuador’s president, Rafael Correa, and Álvaro Uribe, the president of Colombia, should reject the Venezuelan leader’s meddling and manipulation. They should recognize that he is cynically, and dangerously, trying to use their dispute to revive his own flagging political fortunes.

Despite the personal mistrust between the left-leaning Mr. Correa and the right-leaning Mr. Uribe, Ecuador and Colombia have cooperated in the past. Mr. Correa says that Ecuadorean forces have already dismantled many FARC camps.

Colombia must provide reassurances that it will respect Ecuador’s border and that such forays will not be repeated. Ecuador, in turn, must satisfy Colombia that it is not assisting the brutal guerrilla group that has terrorized Colombians for decades.

Colombia’s government claims that during the raid, its troops captured a FARC computer that contained evidence that Mr. Chávez’s government had given $300 million to the guerrilla group. Colombia said files on the computer also indicated Mr. Correa’s government had been harboring FARC members.

Ecuador and Venezuela have denied the charges, but the claims are very worrisome. The two governments should be condemned by the O.A.S. if the information proves to be true. Before that can be addressed, Colombia must share the computer and its data with the O.A.S.

For now, Mr. Correa and Mr. Uribe should cool their rhetoric and begin a serious discussion about how they can jointly secure their borders against the FARC.

Mr. Chávez should just keep quiet. The more he meddles, the easier it is to believe that the charges against him are true.

These kinds of things flare up from time to time, and from what I've heard and read war is not expected. It's probably just Ecuador's President Correa showing an allignment with Chavez that helps him with the poor, but Chavez would be unlikely to be successful in manipulating Correa to begin a war. It's probably much more likely, is that Correa will be thrown out of office when and if they show that he really did harbor FARC. Ecuador as had a lot of instability in that office, with few (if any?) Presidents serving a full term in the last ten years or so.

1 comment:

Shelli said...

I was wondering when this was going to come up... ever since I started talking to my family and friends about this trip I've been hearing concern about the struggles. Hope all ends well.